This article depressed the crap out of me. A three year old asking how many calories are in her turkey sandwich? Way to prepare your child for a lifetime of paranoid and obsession with her weight.
I really do think dealing with childhood obesity should depend on the personality of the kid. I've said before that I have crazy perfectionist qualities. In fourth grade, when I started to gain weight and people started to gently (and not so gently) point it out, I was absolutely devastated. To have this flaw just out there for all the world to see was too much for my type-A little brain to handle. I'd go home from school and cry and beg my mom to write letters getting me out of gym. It was obvious that this was a problem. I still don't know what a good solution would have been.
My parents tried everything, and I know that it was with the best intentions. We went to two different nutritionists, an eating disorder program, and a psychologist. They promised me a pool, vacations, new bedroom furniture and Game Boys if I could lose weight. I went on special diets and they locked junk food up to prevent me from binging on it. I was involved (and awful) in every sport my grammar school offered. Still, my weight went up and I became harder and harder on myself. Truly the definition of the vicious cycle.
That picture above makes me so sad, because I remember the day it was taken and I remember being so down because I felt like a fat cow. Now I look at it and that just blows me away. As an adult, I've watched as a few of my young cousins got a little chunky right around fourth grade, just like I did. It seems like it was just a precursor to puberty and when that finally hit, they grew into their weight. Part of me wonders that if such a big deal wasn't made about my weight that this problem would have dealt with itself.
I do know that I was miserable and dealing with the weight issue made it worse. If my school had started a program about childhood obesity, I would have felt singled out and that would have made it worse. At that age, I just wanted to be like everyone else, and I knew most sixth graders weren't going to dietitians and psychologists, so none of that ended up being very helpful at all.
Solutions? I don't know. I don't think freaking out about your child getting a little chunky is helpful. Maybe head out as a family on walks on a daily basis or something? Overhaul the diets of the whole family instead of the child, but in subtle ways so the little chunky kid doesn't feel like he or she killed dessert for the rest of the family? I don't have children and when I think of issues like this, I am not sure I want to have them. Being a parent seems like the hardest job in the world, and it's not fair that the kids they try to do their best with end up being their harshest critics.
It seems like letting go of trying to be perfect and just trying to be myself helped a lot for me, but it took twenty years of counting calories and feeling guilty about wanting ice cream to do it. Teaching your kid about calories at three? That seems like setting her up for an eating disorder to me.
Do any of you guys have any better ideas on how to deal with this issue or stories about what worked for you? It's still a little hard for me to talk about being a fat kid, which shows how long those wounds take to heal, I suppose, but it's a subject that is really close to my heart.

Hey Taryn, wow. This really hits home for me, and weirdly enough, a friend of mine and I were talking about this very thing today. I grew up an overweight kid (although when I look at pictures, I am nowhere NEAR as fat I as thought I was). My first diet was at the age of 7. I was bingeing on Girl Scout cookies at the age of 8. I also had very high cholesterol (bad genetics).
ReplyDeleteMy brother, on the other hand, was a bean pole, took after the other side of the family genetically, and could eat whatever he want.
So basically, the "treats" were locked away from me (and punishment was doled out if I ate them). And EVERYONE was on notice about my "problem." Friends, family, EVERYONE. Even our German exchange student used to monitor what I ate. I visited him in Germany a few years ago (15 years after I had seen him last) and when he offered me a piece of cake, I almost fell out of my chair!
Like you, I did all the nutritionists, doctors, diets, etc. etc. etc. I even got a 10-speed bike for losing weight! Or the promise of new clothes. Or, the threat of not buying me new, bigger clothes (which only crushed my already low self-esteem). Not surprisingly, I developed a hell of an eating disorder. It is still hard for me to eat a cookie and not feel like someone is standing over my shoulder, waiting to "ground" me for being a "bad girl." Or to believe that I can actually be "beautiful" as a large woman.
I've had a lot of therapy, but still have a long way to go, as far as developing a healthy relationship with food and my body...but I really want one, and I FINALLY feel like I'm on the right track.
One cool thing is that exercise has finally started to become more "fun"...and I do it by choice! In the past, it was literally a punishment. I was forced to be on a swim team (until I lost weight!). Today I actually enjoy swimming, and I'm good at it! And I do other sports, too. I've really had to crush the illusion that I'm not a "jock." Last week I went to see a nutritionist, and she told me I was actually not eating enough calories!! WHAT?!?!! NEVER has a nutritionist, trainer, coach, ANYONE told me to eat MORE calories!! She said, "You're an active woman!!" And she had to really say that several times for it to sink in. I still have that mindset that I'm a fat kid sitting on the couch, even though last year I started doing triathlons and am currently doing roller derby.
I wish I knew what the answer was for childhood obesity. I think as you said, it depends so much on who the child is. It touches such a nerve with me, and like you, I have many pictures of my childhood that are painful to look at, because I remember thinking that I had to hold my stomach in, or I was standing behind a chair on purpose. Ouch. I wish I could hug that little girl today. And I wish I could hug the little girl in your picture as well.
Thanks for writing and for your honesty! It would be a really hard thing for me to put out there in front of people I know.
Ohhh, this entry makes me all mother hen-ish.
ReplyDeleteWhat I noticed in the picture first was your incredibly LONG legs. And I was jealous, wait - not was, are.
I didn't have a weight problem as a child (but I do now - thanks thyroid!), but I had ham sized calfs, or as my mother so kindly called them -"athletic looking".
No boots unless they had a substantial elastic gore. Knee socks weren't. Cankles - yea, I invented those. Yay!
My sister & I refer to them as our Scots-Irish peasant legs. We're draft horse women.
But enough about me and my childhood traumas.
Definitely not putting it all on the child. Doing things that are fun and not "exercise" per se as a family like bike rides, walks after dinner, etc. No diet food. Diet food belongs in the tenth circle of hell and (IMHO) only makes you [me] want more. Portioned sizes of the real thing is so more satisfying.
Internet hug now...
Nice post, and one that I hope is picked up by a few other outlets. (If I can work it into one of my posts, I will.)
ReplyDeleteI think it must be a hard line to walk. Right now Aura and I talk a lot about "getting our exerise," but that's mainly b/c I want her to feel more comfortable taking risks with different forms of physical activity (jumping, stair climbing, certain playgound slides, etc.) My weight fluctuated from middle school on, and I do wonder sometimes whether that points back, just a bit, to my mom, who is wonderful but never particularely enamored of exercise. For now, I'm assuming it's a lot of what you said: promoting activity without actually labeling it that.
I think children get a lot of mixed messages about weight -- they seem to be surrounded by images of skinny celebrities on one hand, and junk food on the other. That has to be confusing and frustrating at the same time. Plus, activity doesn't have to be training for a decathalon. So much emphasis is placed on being "good" at a sport, children who are not "good" get discouraged from any sort of physical activity.
ReplyDeleteCivy, sounds like we went through some of the same things. It's hard because I don't blame my parents because I think they had the best intentions ever, but I was so much harder on myself than anyone else could be that it all just swallowed me up in this sea of feeling "less than" well becoming "more than."
ReplyDeleteLike you, I am still struggling with food issues and guilt and paranoid about eating in front of people, but I'm determined to get better about that too. Life is too short to feel guilty about eating cupcakes.
Congrats on your new-found realization that exercise isn't torture! Thanks so much for your comment. It's always good to know other people were in the same boat.
Kim, yeah, I have always been lucky to be tall! Sorry about your calves. I always find it funny that everyone, no matter how beautiful they seem to the outside world, has a body part they just detest. Where does that come from? Socialization or evolution or some weird brain chemical? Crazy!
ReplyDeleteI am with you on the no-diet food. This new not counting calories and eating what I want thing is so revolutionary to me that it makes me sad. Thanks for the hug! I promise I'm okay and have really good self-esteem now that I'm in my 30's ;)
Kate, yeah, I think being a good example with portion sizes and exercise is probably a good thing for kids too. That way it seems "normal" before any kind of problem develops, I bet.
ReplyDeleteJoanna, totally agree about the sports thing. Again, as I was a crazy little perfectionist, not being good at anything really discouraged me from just doing it for fun. I agree about the media thing too. When a size 10 model is pointed out as plus-sized in a magazine and the editors are praised for including such a wide variety of models, there might be a schism between media life and real life.
Amen Joannafesto: "So much emphasis is placed on being "good" at a sport, children who are not "good" get discouraged from any sort of physical activity."
ReplyDeleteYes - what moron decided size 10 equals a plus size?! I would kill to be a "plus" size 10.
Katherine Hepburn, one of the most beautiful women ever, hated her neck, thought it was too long (?!). If you notice, she usually wears a high necked dress or a scarf in her movies.
Kim, I love Katherine Hepburn! Seriously, women have to stop looking at their flaws and start celebrating their strengths. It sounds so easy, doesn't it?
ReplyDeleteI'm so sorry that you hurt. Nobody is perfect, not even parents. Sometimes a child who is a perfectionist asks for help and a parent who loves them so much tries their best to to get it for them.
ReplyDeleteI love you, Mom :)
ReplyDeleteReading this post brought back all the all that pain I had growing up a fat kid. I was built like my father's family (large) and had a skinny-by-starvation mother who was constantly fixated on the status of not only how big I looked, but what she perceived others thought about HER being the mother of a fat kid. Her approach to helping me with weight loss was humiliation. I don't think she did it to be mean, but because she didn't know any other way. She did things like only give me enough lunch money for 2-3 days since "I could stand to miss a meal" or when we would go out to eat, she would inform the waiter that I would be having a side salad while everyone else ordered full meals "beacuase [I] didn't eat much" (it was the expression on the waiter's face that was the humiliation!). I think that because there was no focus on PROPER eating that when I found myself alone with a shiny new box of Little Debbie Oatmeal Pies that I would inhale the entire thing and hide the empty box anywhere I could so that I wouldn't get in trouble or would trade doing other kid's homework and write their book reports in exchange for candy bars or any other food they could get their hands on. There was always this sense that no matter what I did, how thin I got or what I looked like, it would never be good enough. There would always be something to fix. I would get superficial credit for losing 10 pounds, but then it was time to focus on toning my thunder thighs. So, by logical progression, I consumed whatever I wanted or could get my hands on because it didn't matter...as long as it was in private. The funny thing is, to talk to my mother, she never did any of this stuff. I can't believe that, not only am I fat, but I'm crazy too!
ReplyDeleteI am not a perfectionist in everything, but one constant that I have always had and carry with me even as an adult is that, I don't care what others think about me so much as I care too much what my mother thinks of me. I live my life to figure out how NOT to disappoint her...yet again. She never seemed angry that I was a fat girl, but she always had this look and tone of disappointment and failure that made me feel like I was a disappointment and failure.
I don't think when you grow up a fat girl that these instincts or projections change, you just try to control how much they control you. Because of the focus on image, I still have massive feelings of guilt and shame when it comes to food. I love to cook and exercise my creativity through food, but don't allow myself to even taste my creations. As a current culinary school student, I had a Chef professor teach me how to "taste" my food through sight and smell because I am afraid that the other students in the class will be staring at me and thinking bad things about me if they see me even taste the food. No one comments on or makes fun of the skinny girl in my class that downed 10 glazed donuts on donut making day as she joked that "she just wanted to make sure they tasted good", but I could see the faces examining me to see if I was even going to take a bite while mentally taking bets on how much/fast my hips and thighs would spread when the hot fried dough passed my lips. This may have been perceived, but it's a ghost that haunts me even today.
I don't think I have the answer to childhood obesity. However, I have been contemplating starting a cooking program for kids, teens and adults (and their parents) where the focus is on good, healthy, quality (but yet common and "normal") ingredients and how to put them together, cook, assemble, whatever the recipe takes to make healthy,simple, fun, elegant, impressive dishes that taste amazing and that you can't-wait-to-be-done-making-it-so-you-can-devour-it dishes. Maybe if we focused more on healthy choices in food and exercise (not sports), kids would have a fighting chance that we never had.
Heather, thanks so much for writing that. It seriously feels really great to know I'm not the only one out there that struggles with this stuff 20 years later.
ReplyDeleteI can definitely relate to the embarrassment about eating in front of other people. In college I was so afraid that I'd end up in some reinactment of a scene in "Heathers" with Martha Dumptruck that I used to avoid the dining hall. It's still hard for me, even when out with my best friends who I've known for 25 years, to order what I want, because there's still a part of me that is afraid if I eat fatty food in front of them they'll think I'm pathetic.
How sick is all of this? That's the thing that bothers me most about my weight struggle. It's not how I look. It's how much effing ENERGY goes into all of this stuff. Convincing myself that it's okay to eat what I want, mentally calculating calories, wondering who's watching me, worrying about what other people think in the grocery store, calling myself names when I feel like I've failed... all of it is such a waste. I am so done with it and ready to move on with me life.
That's the real issue for me, the perfectionism and attacking myself so much and not being able to let go of the vision that I perceive of other people having of me. 98% of me thinks "This is me, take it or leave it." That very vocal 2% is still concerned about being the perfect skinny Jessica Wakefield-esque teenager/young adult.
If I were fat but happy and not dealing with these types of issues, I'd be completely happy with being overweight. There are so many beautiful larger woman who carry themselves with confidence and grace. Then there are those of us who try to camouflage with strategic bangs and waist-panel jeans.
I think your idea about the cooking program is great! Efforts like that, involving the whole family before anyone has a problem, seem like they'd be a lot more effective than having programs in schools where kids who already have a target on their backs are singled out and shamed.
Thanks again. You guys are so great for sharing all of this. It's meant a lot to me to be able to read them.
As a child I didn't really have direction on what or what not to eat. My mother was slightly oblivious to these things and well a lot of things. She tried her best don't get me wrong but raising three girls on your own is difficult as it is. Then couple that with us being rather destitute we ate what we had. There wasn't a lot of the whole oh well this isn't healthy for you kind of stuff it was food.
ReplyDeleteSorry short of starting my own post in your comments ;-) I feel for you for sure. At least your family tried to help in their best possible ways. :) I starved myself for a few years that didn't work. I was athletically involved...that didn't help either. *shrug* Now it's just the nazis in me that has to reel it in and clinch down. NO MORE!
Have a terrific day girl
Reading this post brought back all the all that pain I had growing up a fat kid. I was built like my father's family (large) and had a skinny-by-starvation mother who was constantly fixated on the status of not only how big I looked, but what she perceived others thought about HER being the mother of a fat kid. Her approach to helping me with weight loss was humiliation. I don't think she did it to be mean, but because she didn't know any other way. She did things like only give me enough lunch money for 2-3 days since "I could stand to miss a meal" or when we would go out to eat, she would inform the waiter that I would be having a side salad while everyone else ordered full meals "beacuase [I] didn't eat much" (it was the expression on the waiter's face that was the humiliation!). I think that because there was no focus on PROPER eating that when I found myself alone with a shiny new box of Little Debbie Oatmeal Pies that I would inhale the entire thing and hide the empty box anywhere I could so that I wouldn't get in trouble or would trade doing other kid's homework and write their book reports in exchange for candy bars or any other food they could get their hands on. There was always this sense that no matter what I did, how thin I got or what I looked like, it would never be good enough. There would always be something to fix. I would get superficial credit for losing 10 pounds, but then it was time to focus on toning my thunder thighs. So, by logical progression, I consumed whatever I wanted or could get my hands on because it didn't matter...as long as it was in private. The funny thing is, to talk to my mother, she never did any of this stuff. I can't believe that, not only am I fat, but I'm crazy too!
ReplyDeleteI am not a perfectionist in everything, but one constant that I have always had and carry with me even as an adult is that, I don't care what others think about me so much as I care too much what my mother thinks of me. I live my life to figure out how NOT to disappoint her...yet again. She never seemed angry that I was a fat girl, but she always had this look and tone of disappointment and failure that made me feel like I was a disappointment and failure.
I don't think when you grow up a fat girl that these instincts or projections change, you just try to control how much they control you. Because of the focus on image, I still have massive feelings of guilt and shame when it comes to food. I love to cook and exercise my creativity through food, but don't allow myself to even taste my creations. As a current culinary school student, I had a Chef professor teach me how to "taste" my food through sight and smell because I am afraid that the other students in the class will be staring at me and thinking bad things about me if they see me even taste the food. No one comments on or makes fun of the skinny girl in my class that downed 10 glazed donuts on donut making day as she joked that "she just wanted to make sure they tasted good", but I could see the faces examining me to see if I was even going to take a bite while mentally taking bets on how much/fast my hips and thighs would spread when the hot fried dough passed my lips. This may have been perceived, but it's a ghost that haunts me even today.
I don't think I have the answer to childhood obesity. However, I have been contemplating starting a cooking program for kids, teens and adults (and their parents) where the focus is on good, healthy, quality (but yet common and "normal") ingredients and how to put them together, cook, assemble, whatever the recipe takes to make healthy,simple, fun, elegant, impressive dishes that taste amazing and that you can't-wait-to-be-done-making-it-so-you-can-devour-it dishes. Maybe if we focused more on healthy choices in food and exercise (not sports), kids would have a fighting chance that we never had.
Kate, yeah, I think being a good example with portion sizes and exercise is probably a good thing for kids too. That way it seems "normal" before any kind of problem develops, I bet.
ReplyDeleteJoanna, totally agree about the sports thing. Again, as I was a crazy little perfectionist, not being good at anything really discouraged me from just doing it for fun. I agree about the media thing too. When a size 10 model is pointed out as plus-sized in a magazine and the editors are praised for including such a wide variety of models, there might be a schism between media life and real life.
Civy, sounds like we went through some of the same things. It's hard because I don't blame my parents because I think they had the best intentions ever, but I was so much harder on myself than anyone else could be that it all just swallowed me up in this sea of feeling "less than" well becoming "more than."
ReplyDeleteLike you, I am still struggling with food issues and guilt and paranoid about eating in front of people, but I'm determined to get better about that too. Life is too short to feel guilty about eating cupcakes.
Congrats on your new-found realization that exercise isn't torture! Thanks so much for your comment. It's always good to know other people were in the same boat.
Ohhh, this entry makes me all mother hen-ish.
ReplyDeleteWhat I noticed in the picture first was your incredibly LONG legs. And I was jealous, wait - not was, are.
I didn't have a weight problem as a child (but I do now - thanks thyroid!), but I had ham sized calfs, or as my mother so kindly called them -"athletic looking".
No boots unless they had a substantial elastic gore. Knee socks weren't. Cankles - yea, I invented those. Yay!
My sister & I refer to them as our Scots-Irish peasant legs. We're draft horse women.
But enough about me and my childhood traumas.
Definitely not putting it all on the child. Doing things that are fun and not "exercise" per se as a family like bike rides, walks after dinner, etc. No diet food. Diet food belongs in the tenth circle of hell and (IMHO) only makes you [me] want more. Portioned sizes of the real thing is so more satisfying.
Internet hug now...